If a potential contract meets or exceeds a relevant threshold then the contracting authority has to use one of those procedures?

Yes, where the relevant threshold is exceeded (assuming the contract is not an “exempt contract” as set out in schedule 2 to the Act) then the contracting authority will need to either: (1) follow an open, a competitive flexible or a direct award procedure, or (2) use a framework agreement or a dynamic market in order to award a contract.

In what instance(s) would you be able to modify award criteria?

These can be “refined” in accordance with section 24 of the Act; that is, where the tender notice or procurement documents make provision for this and where the invitation to tender has not yet been released. The Explanatory Notes to the Act give the example of after the negotiation stage in a multistage competitive flexible process. However, refinements are not permitted if, had the refinement been made earlier, a supplier who did not progress through an earlier round of the competition, would have done so. Refinements also cannot be made after the authority has invited final tenders. If criteria are refined, the tender notice and procurement documents must be republished. Therefore, the value of this provision may well be limited in practice.

Where does calling off a framework sit as one of the procedures? Both under the existing regulations and the new Act?

As currently, calling off from a framework is not amongst the prescribed procedures; a call off contract is made in accordance with the terms of the framework and in accordance with the legislation (that is, Regulation 33 of the PCR 2015 and sections 45 to 49 of the Act). To set up the framework agreement itself (as opposed to calling off under it), one of the standard procedures must be followed.

Can a framework be opened to new suppliers without changing the terms at all?

We assume this question relates to the new concept of “open” frameworks under the Act, set out at section 49 . Open frameworks are a scheme of successive framework agreements that allow new suppliers to be added at set times during the framework’s lifetime.

Can we still use a selection questionnaire in an Open Framework?

You would certainly expect to use a selection questionnaire when setting up the open framework, not least as section 45(6) states that the framework may not permit the award of a call off contract to an excluded supplier nor prohibit the authority from requesting additional information from suppliers prior to call off (which we assume is the right to re-test the selection criteria at call-off stage).

Open Framework Agreement – is this similar to a DPS? How would you add suppliers, would it need to be based on the same quality/price/social value tender pack that was used for the initial framework?

It is not identical to a DPS in that it does not allow new suppliers to be added at any time, only at certain, fixed joining points which are set out at the beginning of the life of the framework. Section 49(4) does contain detail around the circumstances where an existing supplier who is already on the open framework can be reappointed to its next iteration, without the need for further competition. However, it does not contain detail on how new suppliers may join the open framework at a joining point, although this is clearly contemplated as being possible (see paragraph 322 of the Explanatory Notes to the Act). This is an area where we are expecting further policy/guidance to clarify the position (expected in February 2024). Given that the open framework can only be reiterated where it is on substantially the same terms as previously, we presume that the same quality/price/social value criteria will need to be used.

Regarding open frameworks, is framework 3 let within 5 years of framework 2 or 5 years of framework 1?

A open framework must be reopened (1) at least once during the first 3 years after the date of the award of the first framework and (2) at least once every 5 years after the date of the award of the second framework. However, the open framework could be re-opened on a more frequent basis - e.g., annually - if desired. Each framework expires when the successive framework is awarded; the maximum overall term of an open framework is 8 years.

Will we be able to use the flexible framework regime for existing frameworks?

No, the new open framework concept only comes into force with the Act itself; the Act will not apply to any frameworks (or call off contracts under them) that are in existence prior to the implementation date of the Act. See our blog post here for more on the planned transition period.

Regarding a fixed fee for frameworks; will a variable percentage based on value bands will be lawful? I.e., a contract between £0-£1m might attract 2%, £1-£2m, might attract 1.5%, £2m might attract 2.0%? Will this apply to dynamic markets too?

The Act does it clear that a fee may be charged on contracts awarded under frameworks and under dynamic markets but is silent on percentages. We are awaiting further policy/guidance (expected February 2024) to confirm whether there are any parameters around the level of the fee that may be set.

Will standstill notices apply to direct awards under a framework?

Section 51(3)(d) makes it clear that there is no requirement to hold a standstill period in relation to a contract called off from a framework. The obligation to publish a Contract Details Notice does apply to contracts called off from a framework (see section 50(1) ). Where the call off is by way of a direct award, our reading is that an assessment summary will not however be required, because there will be no “assessed tender” as defined in this section, because there is no mini-competition in this scenario. A later session on award of contracts and standstill will focus in more detail on Contract Details Notices and assessment summaries.

Will there be an opportunity to take advantage of new direct award grounds (e.g., prototypes/development) during the transition period (i.e., before the Act comes into force)?

The transitional provisions are currently in draft but do not permit this currently; these concepts will only come into existence with the implementation of the Act itself (expected October 2024). See our blog post here for more on the planned transition period.

Re: Direct Awards. Will there still be an ability to direct award through an established framework, if the framework so provides?

Yes, the direct awards covered in this part of the webinar were direct awards with no competition and not under a framework. Direct awards of call-off under a framework will still be possible, in the circumstances set out at section 45(4) .

Has the mandatory standstill decreased from 10 to 8 working days?

At present the standstill period is 10 calendar days (ending always on a working day). Under the Act, the standstill period is 8 working days.

Routes to procurement

This webinar focuses on the impact of the Procurement Act 2023 on five different routes to procurement.

Below you can watch a video recording and read some questions and answers from the webinar.

Contacts

Dominic Taylor

Senior Associate
Dominic Taylor

Senior Associate

+(44)(0)1223 222452

Contact Dominic

Contact Dominic Taylor

* = required

First name *

Please enter your first name

Last name *

Please enter your last name

Organisation

Email address *

Please enter your email address Please enter a valid email address

Phone number

Your message *

Please add your message

Send enquiry

Mills & Reeve will use the information you provide in this form in accordance with our privacy policy. We may from time to time send you general updates by email or post that we think you will find of interest. This includes notification of upcoming event and updates or alerts containing relevant legal news. You can update your preferences at any time and will be able to easily unsubscribe from anything that you do not wish to receive.

check

Thank you

Thank you for your enquiry. We will be in touch shortly.

Close

Reset form

Close overlay

Cambridge
Jenny Beresford-Jones

Senior Legal Advisor
Jenny Beresford-Jones

Senior Legal Advisor

+(44)(0)161 235 5422

Contact Jenny

Contact Jenny Beresford-Jones

* = required

First name *

Please enter your first name

Last name *

Please enter your last name

Organisation

Email address *

Please enter your email address Please enter a valid email address

Phone number

Your message *

Please add your message

Send enquiry

Mills & Reeve will use the information you provide in this form in accordance with our privacy policy. We may from time to time send you general updates by email or post that we think you will find of interest. This includes notification of upcoming event and updates or alerts containing relevant legal news. You can update your preferences at any time and will be able to easily unsubscribe from anything that you do not wish to receive.

check

Thank you

Thank you for your enquiry. We will be in touch shortly.

Close

Reset form

Close overlay

Manchester

View more webinars

Our collection of webinars where our procurement experts address public procurement in the UK, focussing on topics that those working with public procurement need to consider.

Key questions and answers

A number of questions were raised during the session, which we have anonymised and answered below.

Procurement procedures under the Act

If a potential contract meets or exceeds a relevant threshold then the contracting authority has to use one of those procedures?

Yes, where the relevant threshold is exceeded (assuming the contract is not an “exempt contract” as set out in schedule 2 to the Act) then the contracting authority will need to either: (1) follow an open, a competitive flexible or a direct award procedure, or (2) use a framework agreement or a dynamic market in order to award a contract.
In what instance(s) would you be able to modify award criteria?

These can be “refined” in accordance with section 24 of the Act; that is, where the tender notice or procurement documents make provision for this and where the invitation to tender has not yet been released. The Explanatory Notes to the Act give the example of after the negotiation stage in a multistage competitive flexible process. However, refinements are not permitted if, had the refinement been made earlier, a supplier who did not progress through an earlier round of the competition, would have done so. Refinements also cannot be made after the authority has invited final tenders. If criteria are refined, the tender notice and procurement documents must be republished. Therefore, the value of this provision may well be limited in practice.

Framework Agreements under the Act

Where does calling off a framework sit as one of the procedures? Both under the existing regulations and the new Act?

As currently, calling off from a framework is not amongst the prescribed procedures; a call off contract is made in accordance with the terms of the framework and in accordance with the legislation (that is, Regulation 33 of the PCR 2015 and sections 45 to 49 of the Act). To set up the framework agreement itself (as opposed to calling off under it), one of the standard procedures must be followed.
Can a framework be opened to new suppliers without changing the terms at all?

We assume this question relates to the new concept of “open” frameworks under the Act, set out at section 49. Open frameworks are a scheme of successive framework agreements that allow new suppliers to be added at set times during the framework’s lifetime.
Can we still use a selection questionnaire in an Open Framework?

You would certainly expect to use a selection questionnaire when setting up the open framework, not least as section 45(6) states that the framework may not permit the award of a call off contract to an excluded supplier nor prohibit the authority from requesting additional information from suppliers prior to call off (which we assume is the right to re-test the selection criteria at call-off stage).
Open Framework Agreement – is this similar to a DPS? How would you add suppliers, would it need to be based on the same quality/price/social value tender pack that was used for the initial framework?

It is not identical to a DPS in that it does not allow new suppliers to be added at any time, only at certain, fixed joining points which are set out at the beginning of the life of the framework.

Section 49(4) does contain detail around the circumstances where an existing supplier who is already on the open framework can be reappointed to its next iteration, without the need for further competition. However, it does not contain detail on how new suppliers may join the open framework at a joining point, although this is clearly contemplated as being possible (see paragraph 322 of the Explanatory Notes to the Act). This is an area where we are expecting further policy/guidance to clarify the position (expected in February 2024). Given that the open framework can only be reiterated where it is on substantially the same terms as previously, we presume that the same quality/price/social value criteria will need to be used.
Regarding open frameworks, is framework 3 let within 5 years of framework 2 or 5 years of framework 1?

A open framework must be reopened (1) at least once during the first 3 years after the date of the award of the first framework and (2) at least once every 5 years after the date of the award of the second framework. However, the open framework could be re-opened on a more frequent basis - e.g., annually - if desired. Each framework expires when the successive framework is awarded; the maximum overall term of an open framework is 8 years.
Will we be able to use the flexible framework regime for existing frameworks?

No, the new open framework concept only comes into force with the Act itself; the Act will not apply to any frameworks (or call off contracts under them) that are in existence prior to the implementation date of the Act. See our blog post here for more on the planned transition period.
Regarding a fixed fee for frameworks; will a variable percentage based on value bands will be lawful? I.e., a contract between £0-£1m might attract 2%, £1-£2m, might attract 1.5%, £2m might attract 2.0%? Will this apply to dynamic markets too?

The Act does it clear that a fee may be charged on contracts awarded under frameworks and under dynamic markets but is silent on percentages. We are awaiting further policy/guidance (expected February 2024) to confirm whether there are any parameters around the level of the fee that may be set.
Will standstill notices apply to direct awards under a framework?

Section 51(3)(d) makes it clear that there is no requirement to hold a standstill period in relation to a contract called off from a framework. The obligation to publish a Contract Details Notice does apply to contracts called off from a framework (see section 50(1)). Where the call off is by way of a direct award, our reading is that an assessment summary will not however be required, because there will be no “assessed tender” as defined in this section, because there is no mini-competition in this scenario. A later session on award of contracts and standstill will focus in more detail on Contract Details Notices and assessment summaries.

Direct Awards

Will there be an opportunity to take advantage of new direct award grounds (e.g., prototypes/development) during the transition period (i.e., before the Act comes into force)?

The transitional provisions are currently in draft but do not permit this currently; these concepts will only come into existence with the implementation of the Act itself (expected October 2024). See our blog post here for more on the planned transition period.
Re: Direct Awards. Will there still be an ability to direct award through an established framework, if the framework so provides?

Yes, the direct awards covered in this part of the webinar were direct awards with no competition and not under a framework. Direct awards of call-off under a framework will still be possible, in the circumstances set out at section 45(4).

Standstill Period

Watch more webinars on-demand

Please click below to visit our YouTube playlists and subscribe to our channel to watch our collection of insightful webinars.

Watch now

Sign up to future webinars

Our webinars are delivered by our legal experts to help you keep up to date with topical subjects in the sector.